Getting Group By Count In Left Outer Join
Posted April 26, 2006 at 4:28 PM by Ben Nadel
Sometimes I amazed that I just miss the most obvious solutions. I was running a query that had a left outer join on a list of vendors, joining to orders (purchase orders). I wanted to get the count of orders per vendor, so I was just getting the COUNT(*) of the Group BY.
The problem with this technique is that the COUNT(*) counts the vendor in the left outer join, not just the orders in the right portion of the join. To solve this, I started to do crazy queries involving sub-queries. It was nuts. Then, it dawned on me... I DON'T have to do COUNT(*). I can do counts on specific columns. And hence:
( ISNULL( COUNT(r.id), 0 ) ) AS reward_count,
( ISNULL( SUM(r.price), 0 ) ) AS price_sum,
( 0 ) AS reward_count_percent,
( 0 ) AS price_sum_percent
LEFT OUTER JOIN
t.id = vtjn.vendor_type_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN
vtjn.vendor_id = r.vendor_id
As you can see, the COUNT() runs on r.id. This way, it can return a Type row with a count of zero. The only caveat is that you have to check for NULL values on the COUNT (and the SUM) since there might not be any records in the right portion of the JOIN.
What Other People Are Searching For
Wouldn't you only have to do the ISNULL for SUM? COUNT (at least on MSSQL) should have a count of 0 (zero) for NULL values.
You might be correct on that, cause COUNT() should return zero if there are no records. Good call.
Thanks for this... I was also about to embark on a crazy sub-query journey.
thanks for the code.
Hi Thanks for this Code!
LG from Austria
It was had been a while since I last did this.. I forgot that I had to use group by to get all my listings :D
Glad to help out :)
Thanks this helped a bunch. I was trying to count the comments associated to a topic, and I didn't want to run subqueries. BTW, for MySQL the command is IfNull
Glad I came across your posting because it didn't dawn on me initially to do it this way either. Your post saved me from going down the crazy query road.
Glad to help.
Thanks for the MySQL tip. I used to do only MS SQL, but now, we use mostly MySQL at work, so that helps.
rewrite the given query without using join and group by
select b.title,max(bc.returneddate-bc.checkoutdate) ''most days out'' from bookshelf_checkout bc,bookshelf b where bc.title(+)=b.title group by b.title;
Thanks for the tip - I was stuck on this one too!
Glad to help.
Thanks for this blog. I was stuck with the COUNT(*) when I really wanted to count only one column. It didn't even click to me until I visit your bolg.
This SQL isn't syntatically correct as ISNULL() only takes 1 parameter. I would suggest something along the lines of:
IF( ISNULL( COUNT(r.id)), 0, COUNT(r.id) ) AS reward_count
What SQL engine are you using? I definitely ran this code before it was posted and it worked just fine.
It's been a rough four years ago since you've posted this, but it definitely works!
Worked great. Thanks for the tip!
That worked for me too